体外体内外推法应用于风险评估的文献计量和可视化分析

Bibliometric and visual analysis of in vitro-in vivo extrapolation in risk assessment

  • 摘要:
    背景 体外体内外推法(IVIVE)是一种利用体外实验数据来预测体内现象的方法,目前被认为是一种很有前景的化学品风险评估工具。
    目的 通过检索文献和文献计量分析,了解IVIVE用于风险评估的研究热点、演进路径和发展态势,为后续研究提供方向借鉴和数据支持。
    方法 选择美国国家医学图书馆文献数据库查询系统(PubMed)和Web of Science的核心合集(WoSCC)为外文数据库,检索IVIVE应用于风险评估研究领域2023年12月31日之前发表的文献。中国知网和万方数据库中相关文献数量过少,因此中文数据库暂不纳入本研究。采用文献计量学的方法,利用VOSviewer和CiteSpace,分别以作者、机构、国家、期刊、关键词及共被引情况为切入点进行可视化分析。
    结果 本研究共纳入189篇文献。IVIVE用于风险评估研究的第一篇论文在2006年发表,之后发文量总体呈上升趋势,尤其2016年后显著增加;发文量最多的机构是美国环境保护局(28篇);美国是发文量最多的国家(87篇),并与英国有着紧密的合作;发文量最多且篇均被引量最高的期刊是Archives of Toxicology(19篇)。关键词共现分析提示:IVIVE应用于风险评估时主要研究体外体内外推的方法和模型、化学品毒性的预测等,毒性、体外和模型等均是该领域的研究热点。关键词时间轴聚类分析提示:评估对象从药物逐渐扩展到环境化学品、有机化学品和食品添加剂等。共被引分析提示,IVIVE用于风险评估研究领域的文章较多引用环境、食品和药品领域的期刊,主要是方法学研究,其次是文献综述。
    结论 被应用于风险评估研究领域的IVIVE正在快速发展,随着预测模型的完善,应用范围的扩大,可极大地减少动物实验在风险评估中的应用,提高风险评估的效率。目前,美国在该领域具有领先地位,而中国相关研究较少,需要积极开展国际合作,提升IVIVE的应用研究水平。未来,希望IVIVE方法能够进一步完善,提升其应用研究水平和拓展其研究领域。

     

    Abstract:
    Background In vitro-in vivo extrapolation (IVIVE) is an approach utilizing in vitro experimental data to predict in vivo phenomena. It is a promising tool for chemical risk assessment.
    Objective To learn the hotspots, evolution path, and trend of IVIVE in risk assessment by literature search and bibliometric analysis, and provide reference and data support for subsequent research.
    Methods PubMed and Web of Science Core Collection were selected as foreign databases to search for literature about IVIVE applied in risk assessment published by December 31, 2023. The number of relevant documents in CNKI and Wanfang database was too small, so the Chinese databases were not included in this study. This study employed bibilometric analysis using VOSviewer and CiteSpace for visualizing networks categorized by author, institution, country, journal, keyword, and co-citation.
    Results A total of 189 articles were included in this study. The first article was published in 2006, and since then the number of publications overall showed an upward trend and increased significantly after 2016. The institution with the most publications was the United States Environmental Protection Agency (28 articles). The United States was the most productive country (87 articles), and had a close cooperation with the United Kingdom. The journal with the most publications and the highest number of citations per article was Archives of Toxicology (19 articles). The keyword co-occurrence analysis suggested that research on IVIVE in risk assessment mainly studied the methods and models of IVIVE and prediction of chemical toxicity, and toxicity, in vitro, and models were the research hotspots in this field. Keyword timeline cluster analysis suggested that the assessment objects gradually expanded from drugs to environmental chemicals, organic chemicals and food additives. The co-citation analysis suggested that articles about IVIVE in risk assessment mostly cited journals in the environment, food, and drug fields, and these articles were mainly methodological studies followed by literature reviews.
    Conclusion The research of IVIVE in risk assessment has developed rapidly. With the improvement of prediction models and the expansion of application scope, animal experiments in risk assessment may be greatly reduced and the efficiency of risk assessment can be increased. At present, the United States has a leading position in this field, while China has few relevant studies and needs to actively carry out international cooperation to improve the level of applied research of IVIVE. In the future, it is hoped that the IVIVE method can be further refined to improve its application and expand its research fields.

     

/

返回文章
返回